TBoard by muted labs
The Name Behind the Conservation Laws — lesson illustration Advanced

PEOPLE & HISTORY

The Name Behind the Conservation Laws

  • 13 spell
  • 8 known
  • 2 semi-open
  • 6 open
  • 2 math
Print / Download PDF
Play app demo
Lesson preview

THE MATHEMATICIAN WHO COULD NOT BE HIRED

In 1915 David HILBERT and Felix Klein brought a young ALGEBRAIST from Erlangen to Göttingen to help with a puzzle in Einstein's new theory of GRAVITATION. She could not be hired. German universities required a HABILITATION, the second thesis and formal examination that granted the right to lecture, and the philosophical faculty refused to open it to a woman, arguing that soldiers returning from the front would be insulted by a female instructor. For four years her courses appeared in the catalogue under Hilbert's name, taught by her. The mathematics was hers.

  1. SPELL
    ALGEBRAIST
  2. SPELL
    GRAVITATION
  3. KNOWN
    German universities of the time demanded a second thesis and a formal examination before a scholar was granted the right to lecture. What was that qualification called?
    Answer: HABILITATION
  4. KNOWN
    What was the last name of the Göttingen mathematician who, with Felix Klein, brought the young algebraist from Erlangen?
    Answer: HILBERT
  5. OPEN
    The faculty argued that returning soldiers would be insulted by a woman lecturing. What is the weakest reason you have ever heard for keeping someone out?

SYMMETRY AS BOOKKEEPING

The problem she was handed concerned ENERGY in Einstein's theory, and her answer ran far past it. Physics states its laws through a VARIATIONAL principle: a system follows the path that extremizes the action, a single quantity accumulated along the whole trajectory. She proved that whenever the action is left unchanged by a continuous transformation, an INVARIANCE, a matching CONSERVATION law follows automatically. Shift the clock, and energy is conserved. Shift the origin in space, and MOMENTUM is conserved. Rotate the phase of a charged field, and CHARGE is conserved. SYMMETRY is not a hint about the laws; it is their bookkeeping.

  1. SPELL
    VARIATIONAL
  2. SPELL
    INVARIANCE
  3. KNOWN
    What is the term for the property that is not a hint about the laws of physics but their bookkeeping?
    Answer: SYMMETRY
  4. KNOWN
    What is the term for a law guaranteeing that a quantity stays fixed because a continuous transformation leaves the action unchanged?
    Answer: CONSERVATION
  5. SEMI-OPEN
    Name two of the quantities that a symmetry keeps conserved.
    Needs 2 of: ENERGY, MOMENTUM, CHARGE
  6. OPEN
    Shift the clock and energy is conserved; shift the origin and momentum is. What is something in your life that stays the same no matter where you start counting?

KEEP THE AXIOMS

The theorem was, by her own reckoning, a detour. Her real program was abstract algebra, and her method was to discard the objects and keep the axioms. An ideal is a subset of a ring that absorbs multiplication by anything in the ring. In 1921 she showed that a single FINITENESS assumption — the ASCENDING chain condition, which forbids any strictly increasing chain of ideals from running forever — forces decomposition results that earlier mathematicians had proved case by case. GROUPS, RINGS, FIELDS, and MODULES stopped being separate subjects and became one, linked by the HOMOMORPHISM, a map that preserves structure rather than content.

  1. SPELL
    HOMOMORPHISM
  2. SPELL
    FINITENESS
  3. KNOWN
    What is the chain condition called that forbids any strictly increasing chain of ideals from running on forever?
    Answer: ASCENDING
  4. SEMI-OPEN
    Name two of the algebraic structures her axiomatic method treated alike.
    Needs 2 of: GROUPS, RINGS, FIELDS, MODULES
  5. OPEN
    Her method threw away the objects and kept only the rules they obey. What is one question you would ask her about working that way?

THE SECOND THEOREM

The 1918 paper contains two theorems, and the second is the stranger one. The first covers global symmetries, transformations applied identically everywhere. The second covers GAUGE symmetry, whose parameter can be chosen freely at every separate point, as in electromagnetism, and general COVARIANCE, the freedom of general relativity to be written in any coordinate system at all. Local symmetry buys less than it appears to: instead of independent conservation laws it yields identities among the field equations themselves, the contracted BIANCHI identities in gravity. That is why energy in general relativity refuses to behave the way energy behaves elsewhere.

  1. SPELL
    COVARIANCE
  2. SPELL
    BIANCHI
  3. KNOWN
    What is a symmetry called when its parameter can be chosen freely and independently at every separate point?
    Answer: GAUGE
  4. OPEN
    Local symmetry buys less than it seems to. What is something that looked like a rule and turned out to be an accounting trick?
  5. MATH
    In four-dimensional spacetime, the Einstein field equations have 10 independent components, and the contracted Bianchi identities impose 4 constraints among them. How many independent equations are left?
    Answer: 6

THE NAME ON THE COVER

The faculty relented in 1919; an unofficial PROFESSORSHIP and a small STIPEND followed in 1922. Her lectures reached print through van der Waerden's Moderne Algebra in 1930, carrying her ideas to a generation that never saw her name on the cover. EPONYMY, the habit of hanging a discoverer's name onto a result, is a poor memory system: the label survives, the person evaporates. In 1933 the civil service law expelled her, and she taught at Bryn Mawr until her death two years later at fifty-three. Einstein wrote to the New York Times calling her the most significant creative mathematical genius since the higher education of women began.

  1. SPELL
    EPONYMY
  2. SPELL
    PROFESSORSHIP
  3. SPELL
    STIPEND
  4. OPEN
    Her ideas reached a generation that never saw her name on the cover. Whose work do you use every day without knowing who did it?

WHY ANYTHING STAYS PUT

You lean on her result whenever you trust that something stays put. A skater pulling her arms inward spins faster because space looks the same in every direction, and that rotational symmetry hands her a fixed ANGULAR momentum. Charge does not quietly drain out of your phone's circuits because the gauge symmetry of ELECTROMAGNETISM forbids it. Where the symmetry is missing, so is the guarantee: light from distant galaxies arrives stretched toward the red, a REDSHIFT, having lost energy on the way, because an expanding universe offers no time-translation symmetry to conserve it. The UNBREAKABLE laws are conditional, and the condition was proved by a woman whose name you were probably never given.

  1. SPELL
    ELECTROMAGNETISM
  2. SPELL
    UNBREAKABLE
  3. KNOWN
    What kind of momentum does a skater keep fixed when she pulls her arms in and spins faster?
    Answer: ANGULAR
  4. KNOWN
    What is the term for light from distant galaxies arriving stretched toward longer wavelengths, having lost energy crossing an expanding universe?
    Answer: REDSHIFT
  5. OPEN
    A skater spins faster the moment she pulls her arms in. When have you felt something speed up just by pulling in?
  6. MATH
    A skater conserves angular momentum, so cutting her moment of inertia to a third multiplies her spin rate by three. Suppose she turns at 2 rotations per second with her arms out. How many rotations per second does she make once her arms are in?
    Answer: 6

Enjoy the lesson? Get the TBoard app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Sources consulted for the facts in this lesson